blog

date

March 26, 2025

blog

reading time

5 min

Restaurant Reward Programs vs Discounts: What Drives More Profit?

Restaurant rewards programs and restaurant discounts are both great strategies to attract and retain customers without being too expensive or harsh on restaurant profit margins to introduce.

‍

They are meant to be incentives for guests to return and become a loyal customer, which, in turn, drives restaurant profit.

Although both strategies are useful for retaining customers and driving profit, each strategy has their pros and cons, making the decision hard for restaurants starting out on their customer retention journey.

Top-down view of people sharing food at a restaurant table with the overlay text “Restaurant Reward Programs vs Discounts.”

‍

Which strategy will actually drive more profit for your restaurant?

Discounts bring in quick traffic, but are they sustainable for long-term profit?

Reward programs promise loyalty and repeat business, but require upfront investment and strategy.

‍

In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of both strategies, as well as teach you when to use each, to help you choose the smarter path and make informed decisions for your restaurant success.

‍

The Psychology Behind Discounts & Rewards

Understanding consumer psychology is key to choosing the right strategy.

‍

Close-up of the word “membership” highlighted in a printed dictionary or book page.

‍

Discounts

Discounts tap into a customer's weakness of immediate gratification.

‍

They want a quick win and will spark impulse purchases that won't incentivize customer loyalty in the long term.

It is known that customers are more likely to try your restaurant if there are food rewards like a “limited-time 20% off” deal, but this mindset is purely transactional.

Once the deal ends, so does the relationship, or in this case, loyalty.

‍

Reward Programs

Reward programs run on the idea of delayed gratification for both the restaurant and the customer.

‍

Earning points or perks builds a sense of investment to the restaurant and the restaurant loyalty program which motivates valuable customers to return again and again.

Customers feel they’re working toward a goal, fostering brand loyalty and constant engagement, creating an emotional connection with your dining establishment.

This leads to repeat visits and a longer customer lifetime value (CLV), creating lifetime valuable guests.

Exclusive rewards tap into the motivation and habit formation part of the brain, making them a powerful long-term tool for customer retention and profit driving.

‍

Pros & Cons of Restaurant Reward Programs

‍

‍

Pros:

Boosts Customer Retention: Reward programs elevate the customer experience, encouraging guests to return more often to earn and redeem rewards.
Increases Average Ticket Size: Customers often are willing to spend more for qualifying purchases, to reach point thresholds, or to unlock special offers.
Data-Driven Marketing: Reward programs help you gather valuable data for future personalized rewards and strategic upselling.
Builds Brand Loyalty: Customer loyalty programs create emotional and psychological attachments to your brand, giving customers a reason to choose you over competitors.

‍

Cons:

Initial Setup Required: Successful restaurant loyalty programs need the right tech, staff training, and a clear program structure for a seamless transition and integration.
Long-Term ROI: Unlike exclusive deals and promotional offers, rewards take time to show results and need persistence for a high and consistent payoff.
Customer Drop-off: If the rewards program isn’t engaging to customers or too complex to use, customers may stop participating.

‍

Pros & Cons of Restaurant Discounts

‍

A variety of colorful printed coupons with different discount percentages like 10%, 20%, and 50% off.

‍

Pros:

Quick Revenue Boost: Flash sales or limited time exclusive offers can bring in immediate traffic during slow hours.
Easy to Promote: Discounts are a familiar, low-barrier, and effective attention grabbing tactic for any customer base.
Great for Acquiring First-Time Guests: Incentivizes unfamiliar customers to become a frequent customer.

‍

Cons:

Margin Erosion: Frequent discounts reduce profit and make it harder to sustain operations.
Trains Customers to Wait for Deals: Creates a cycle where guests only visit when there’s a promotion.
Short-Term Focus: Doesn’t build long-term customer loyalty or encourage repeat visits on its own.

‍

When to Use Each Strategy

First, restaurant owners need to know their exact goal they are trying to achieve with these customer incentives.

Are they looking to promote a new product?

Do they want to increase their customer base overall?

‍

Discounts are best for short-term goals, such as:

Launching a new location or item
Filling empty tables during off-peak hours
Re-engaging lapsed customers

‍

Reward programs are more effective for long-term strategies:

Increasing average visit frequency
Encouraging higher spending over time
Building a loyal customer base

‍

Choosing based on each restaurant's business stage, current needs, and customer behavior will help them use each tactic more effectively.

‍

Hybrid Approach: Best of Both Worlds?

‍

3D illustration of a laptop with code, gears, cloud syncing, and development icons representing restaurant software tools.

‍

Why choose one when you can have both?

‍

A hybrid approach can blend the strengths of discounts and rewards for maximum benefits.

For example:

Offer limited-time exclusive discounts to loyalty members only
Offer app-exclusive offers for new loyal customers on their loyalty network
Run “Double Points Days” instead of offering 10% off to the public
Give a signup bonus (e.g., free appetizer or $5 off) when customers join your rewards program

This strategy attracts deal-seekers while gradually transitioning them into loyal, repeat customers, and, at the same time, helping you track performance better and fine-tune promotions based on real data.

‍

Tools That Make It Easy

Modern technology takes the hassle out of managing rewards and promotions.

Tools like MenuSifu’s all-in-one POS system can help restaurants:

Automatically track purchases and rewards by customer
Manage dine-in, takeout, and third-party sales in one platform
Run real-time reports to see what’s working

MenuSifu's loyalty program with customer relationship management (CRM) can help restaurants:

Enhance guest loyalty with a loyalty tiers that rewards frequent diners
Automatically adds points for returning customers with every visit, redeemable for exclusive dishes, coupons and gifts
Track customers' dining history and preferences to tailor unique experiences
Send holiday greetings, reminders, and updates to keep customers engaged and informed

With the right tools, setting up and managing a rewards program becomes seamless—and more importantly, profitable.

‍